Are Fish Mammals? (No, And Here’s Why)

Fish with bubble trail in vibrant coral reef

The question of whether fish are mammals might sound simple, but it actually leads us to the interesting details of how animals are classified. Knowing the differences between these groups is a learning experience.

Fish are not mammals. They are part of different animal classes, each with its own unique features. Mammals are warm-blooded and usually have hair or fur, whereas fish are cold-blooded and have scales.

In this article, we’re going to look closely at what sets fish apart from mammals. We’ll explain why this difference matters and clear up some of the common misunderstandings about these two diverse groups of animals.

Why Are Fish Not Mammals?

Tropical fish over coral reef

Fish are not mammals, and the reason is quite clear. Mammals, such as dogs and humans, are warm-blooded, have hair or fur, and feed their babies with milk. They also breathe air using their lungs. 

Fish, however, are quite different. They are cold-blooded, covered in scales, breathe underwater using gills, and lay eggs. These distinct features set fish apart from mammals.

In simpler terms, fish are not mammals because the way we define ‘mammals’ doesn’t include fish. This is because of their different biological traits and the way they live.

Understanding why we classify animals, like separating fish from mammals, is important. This idea of grouping animals was developed by a scientist named Carl Linnaeus in the 1700s. 

It helps us make sense of the many different forms of life on Earth. By putting animals into groups, scientists can study them better, and we can all learn more about how different animals, including us, fit into nature.

Fun Fact: Carl Linnaeus’s method was groundbreaking because he introduced binomial nomenclature. This means he used just two names to identify each species.

Before this, species names were long and complicated. His simpler system made it easier to organize and understand different living creatures.

Fish vs. Mammals: What Are the Differences?

Both fish and mammals are parts of the animal kingdom, but they differ significantly in their biology and the way they live. So, how exactly are they different?

Here’s a quick look at some key differences of fish and mammals:

Body Temperature:
Cold-blooded (their body temperature changes with the environment)
Body Temperature:
Warm-blooded (keep a constant body temperature)
Gills to breathe underwater
Lungs to breathe air
Hair or fur
Most lay eggs
Most give birth to live babies
Live in water
Live on land or in water
Heart Chambers:
Usually 2 chambers (1 atrium, 1 ventricle)
Heart Chambers:
Typically 4 chambers (2 atria, 2 ventricles)
Brain Structure:
Simpler brain structure
Brain Structure:
More complex brain structure
Sensory Organs:
Lateral line system for detecting movements and vibrations in water
Sensory Organs:
Highly developed sense of hearing and smell
Limb Structure:
Fins without digits (webbed)
Limb Structure:
Limbs with digits (fingers or toes)
Blood Circulation:
Single-loop circulation
Blood Circulation:
Double-loop circulation

Fish and mammals are each uniquely suited to their environments. Fish, ideal for aquatic life, breathe with gills and change their body temperature to match the water. They usually have scales and lay eggs. 

Mammals, in contrast, are warm-blooded, maintaining a steady temperature and breathing air with their lungs. They mostly live on land, with some adapted to water, and typically give birth to live young.

Despite these main differences, there are some animals that exhibit traits of both fish and mammals, which can sometimes cause confusion.

The table above outlines some of the key traits of fish and mammals and highlights their main differences. However, keep in mind that there are many exceptions to this simplified comparison.

In learning about animal classification, I’ve seen that the basic rules are helpful but not always perfect. Scientists use a system based on lots of research to classify animals. 

This system changes as we learn more. These discoveries help us understand animal classification better.

Here is a video to better understand the difference between fish and mammals:

Is a fish a mammal?

Fun Fact: Did you know that the lungfish, a type of fish, can breathe air using their lungs the same way mammals do? Despite this, it’s still classified as a fish due to other key characteristics like laying eggs in water.

Why Do People Think Fish Are Mammals?

School of fish in deep blue ocean

The idea that fish might be mammals comes from a few simple mix-ups. Long ago, scientists thought animals like whales, which live in water, were fish. This old mistake can still confuse people today.

Also, some fish act a bit like mammals. Take lungfish, for example. This fish breathes using their lungs and can thrive in dry conditions, similar to most mammals. 

Another example is the jawfish. Male jawfish carry eggs in their mouths, similar to how some mammals care for their young. This behavior can make it seem like they’re mammals.

Additionally, some sea mammals, like dolphins, look a lot like fish. They have similar shapes and live in water, so it’s easy to get them mixed up if you don’t know much about animals.

Lastly, the words we use can cause confusion. In some languages, there isn’t a clear difference between the words for ‘fish’ and ‘sea mammal.’

In short, old scientific mistakes, similar looks and behaviors, and language issues are why some people might think fish are mammals. It’s important to know the real scientific differences between them.

Common Misconceptions About Fish and Mammals

Sometimes, figuring out the animal kingdom can be tricky, especially when it comes to telling different animals apart. For fish and mammals, there are a handful of mix-ups that many people often get confused by. 

Here are some of the most common misconceptions about fish and mammals: 

  • All ocean animals are fish: A common mistake is to label all animals in the ocean as fish. In fact, many of the most well-known sea animals are mammals. This includes the likes of whales and dolphins, which are often mistaken for fish.
  • Cold-blooded versus warm-blooded: There’s a misconception that all ocean animals are cold-blooded. However, mammals like whales and dolphins are actually warm-blooded.
  • Breathing underwater: Some might think that all animals living in the ocean breathe underwater. But marine mammals breathe air using their lungs, whereas fish use gills to extract oxygen from water.
  • Reproduction in water: A common misunderstanding is that all animals in the ocean, including mammals, lay eggs in water to reproduce. However, there are many sea animals that give birth to live young.
  • Movement and fins: It’s often thought that any ocean creature with fins is a fish. However, marine mammals like dolphins and whales also have fin-like structures but are not fish.

These are just some of the examples that showcase the incredible variety and common misconceptions about mammals and fish. 

Recognizing these differences helps us be more accurate in addressing these fascinating creatures.

What Animals Are Mistaken for Fish But Are Actually Mammals?

Animal mistaken for fish

Many sea animals swim elegantly through the water, with their fish-like traits captivating us. However, not all creatures in the sea are fish. Which ones are actually mammals?

Here are some animals that are often mistaken for fish but are in fact mammals:

  • Dolphins: Known for their intelligence and playful nature, dolphins are marine mammals, not fish. They breathe air through their lungs and even nurse their young.
  • Whales: These majestic creatures, including the gigantic blue whale, are mammals. They are warm-blooded, breathe air, and give birth to live young, which they feed with milk.
  • Manatees: Often referred to as sea cows, manatees are gentle, slow-moving mammals. Unlike fish, they have lungs for breathing air and are entirely herbivorous.
  • Seals: While their sleek bodies and aquatic prowess might suggest a fishy lineage, seals are indeed mammals. They have fur, produce milk, and breathe air.
  • Otters: Otters, with their impressive swimming skills, are mammals that spend a significant amount of time in the water. They have fur, and like all mammals, they breathe air.

These are just the most common sea animals that are often mistaken for fish. Aside from these, there are other sea animals like the walrus, sea lions, dugongs, and porpoises, which also share these mammalian traits. 

Each of these animals is adapted to life in the water, yet they all breathe air, nurse their young, and have other distinctive mammalian features that set them apart from fish.

Fun Fact: Although they have the word “fish” in their names, jellyfish and starfish are not fish due to their lack of backbone. 

To address this widespread misconception, many public aquariums and even government bodies have adopted more accurate names, calling them “sea jellies” and “sea stars.” Take note that they are not mammals either.

Frequently Asked Questions

Koi fish swimming with water lilies in a pond

Are Sharks Mammals or Fish?

Sharks are fish. They have skeletons made of cartilage, which is different from the bones in mammals. 

Sharks breathe with gills underwater and are cold-blooded, meaning their body temperature changes with the water around them. These are the main traits that classify sharks as fish.

Are Whales Mammals or Fish?

Whales are mammals. Despite living in water, they breathe air through their lungs and give birth to live young, which they feed with milk. Whales are warm-blooded, keeping their body temperature the same in different environments.

Are Dolphins Mammals or Fish?

Dolphins are mammals. They have lungs to breathe air and give birth to live young, which they nurse with milk. 

Like whales, dolphins are warm-blooded, so their body temperature stays constant, even though they live in the water and look like fish.

Hopefully, this guide has taught you a thing or two about mammals, fish, and how animals are classified. Do you know other fish or mammals that can be mistaken for each other? Leave a comment below!

Leave a Comment

You may also like